BVA Case 22-2575: Back

BVAReal Board of Veterans' Appeals decision · October 8, 2024 · K.A. KENNERLY

Outcome
Remanded
Decision Date
October 8, 2024
Judge
K.A. KENNERLY
Service Era
Not specified

Conditions Claimed

BackKneeHipAnkleTDIUArthritisRadiculopathy

What would this rating pay you? (2026 rates)

Official 2026 VA monthly compensation, including the 2.8% COLA increase.

per month ·  per year, tax-free

Dependent add-ons start at a 30% rating. Child-only and dependent-parent rates: see the full 2026 pay chart.

2026 base rates, all ratings (veteran alone)
RatingMonthly (2026, incl. 2.8% COLA)
10%$180.42
20%$356.66
30%$552.47
40%$795.84
50%$1,132.90
60%$1,435.02
70%$1,808.45
80%$2,102.15
90%$2,362.30
100%$3,938.58
See your full claim picture — free
Sponsored
Missing the medical evidence for your VA claim? REE Medical connects veterans with independent licensed providers for nexus letters and DBQs — $50 off through this link.

Referral disclosure: VetAid earns a referral fee if you become a paying REE Medical client through this link — it helps keep this site free. REE Medical provides paid medical evidence; it is not a law firm, VSO, or claims agent, and VetAid has not independently verified its services. VSOs and VA-accredited representatives will help you file your claim at no cost, and no one can guarantee a rating increase.

Issues on Appeal

BackKneeHipAnkleTDIUArthritisRadiculopathy

Why It Was Decided This Way

2015 examination was inadequate for evaluation purposes and the Board's finding to the contrary was clearly erroneous") (emphasis added).

The DBQ, however, did not address whether there was pain with nonweight-bearing for the right hip in the remarks section, or elsewhere.

for a Right Hip Disability Under DC 5003-5251 Prior to the March 2021 rating decision on appeal, a duty to assist error occurred.

Accordingly, a pre-decisional duty to assist error was committed by not obtaining an adequate examination.

As such, remand is warranted to fulfill VA's duty to assist by obtaining an adequate VA examination, as outlined further in the remand directives below.

As explained above, there was a pre-decisional duty to assist error regarding the increased rating claims for the right hip, which includes those under DCs 5003-5253 and 5003-5251.

The pre-decisional duty to assist error as to the right hip initial rating claims extends to these intertwined claims and, as such, remand is also warranted for these claims.

Entitlement to an Initial Disability Rating in Excess of 10 Percent for a Low Back Disability Prior to the March 2021 rating decision on appeal, a duty to assist error occurred.

Authorities Cited

Barr v. NicholsonBrown v. BrownEsteban v. BrownHedgepeth v. WilkieHorn v. ShinsekiLuca v. BrownPeyton v. DerwinskiPhillips v. McRodriguez v. PeakeSee Correia v. McSee Harris v. DerwinskiSee Hedgepeth v. WilkieSee Lyles v. ShulkinSee Morgan v. WilkieSee Rice v. ShinsekiSee Sharp v. ShulkinSee Stern v. McSharp v. ShulkinStern v. McTerry v. Mc

Regulations Cited (38 CFR / 38 USC)

38 CFR 20.130338 CFR 20.30038 CFR 20.300(a)38 CFR 20.30138 CFR 20.802(a)38 CFR 3.103(c)(2)(ii)38 CFR 3.151(c)38 CFR 3.151(c)(1)38 CFR 3.159(c)(4)(i)38 CFR 3.2500(b)38 CFR 3.260138 CFR 3.2601(f)38 CFR 3.34438 CFR 3.344(a)38 CFR 3.344(c)38 CFR 3.40038 CFR 4.138 CFR 4.1338 CFR 4.238 CFR 4.59

Denial Type

Credibility|Duty To Assist|Inadequate Exam

Find Similar Precedent for Your Claim

VetAid's analyzer maps your claim against thousands of real Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions like this one — surfacing the exact case law that supports your arguments.

Run my claim through VetAid →
Sponsored
Missing the medical evidence for your VA claim? REE Medical connects veterans with independent licensed providers for nexus letters and DBQs — $50 off through this link.

Referral disclosure: VetAid earns a referral fee if you become a paying REE Medical client through this link — it helps keep this site free. REE Medical provides paid medical evidence; it is not a law firm, VSO, or claims agent, and VetAid has not independently verified its services. VSOs and VA-accredited representatives will help you file your claim at no cost, and no one can guarantee a rating increase.