BVA Case 08-3802: Depression
Real Board of Veterans' Appeals decision · November 8,2010 · HAGEL, Judge
Conditions Claimed
DepressionAnxietyPsychiatricBackRespiratory
Issues on Appeal
Back ConditionService ConnectionReopen
Why It Was Decided This Way
Because the Board's findings that VA complied with its duty to assist and provided adequate medical examinations were not clearly erroneous,and because the Board provided an adequate statement of reasons or bases for its decision,the Court will affirm the July 17,2008,Board decision.
In June 1970,the Board denied his claim,finding that [w]hile [ Mr.
A November 1998 rating decision denied his claims for benefits for a sinus condition and a low back disorder because there was no record of treatment in service for these conditions,and denied his claim to reopen because he did not submit new and material evidence.
2 There is no new and material evidence,as the military documents provided by the Department of Army explained the reasons for early discharge (June 4,1994[,]rather than June 29,1994)was due to having served overseas.
Rosa-Solis's claim to reopen his previously denied claim for benefits for a psychiatric disorder because his wife and mother submitted lay statements regarding his emotional and mental state since service,which the Board found was new and material evidence.
Rosa-Solis's claims for benefits for a sinus condition and a low back disorder because it found that VA violated its duty to assist by not obtaining pertinent medical records and failing to provide adequate medical examinations.
Rosa-Solis's medical records, although not completely successful,were sufficient to satisfy VA's duty to assist.
Rosa-Solis's claims for benefits for a sinus disability,low back disorder,and psychiatric disorder because there was no evidence of in-service incurrence or aggravation of any of these conditions and no medical evidence of a nexus between service and his current disabilities.
Authorities Cited
Denial Type
Credibility|No Nexus|Not New Material|Duty To Assist
Find Similar Precedent for Your Claim
VetAid's analyzer maps your claim against thousands of real Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions like this one — surfacing the exact case law that supports your arguments.
Run my claim through VetAid →